The Best Financial Decision I’ve Ever Made

The Best Financial Decision I've Ever MadeIt was September 2001 and I was living in a tiny 500 sq. ft. basement apartment of a big house in the suburbs of Washington D.C.  My $40,000 a year salary placed me slightly below the median income in America, but I had a stable government job. 

I could afford a bigger place, but my frugal tendencies kept me on the path.  I knew that saving on the big three was the fastest way to build wealth.

My lease was up in November, and I was flirting with buying a house but wasn’t sure I could afford it.  The D.C. area was then as it is now the richest area in the country and house prices even then were expensive.

Then 9/11 happened, and my world was rocked like everyone else’s.  I work for the Department of Defense,  so on September 14th I was sent halfway across the country to a military base to assist and deliver training to elite soldiers who would soon be on the front line. 

Most planes weren’t even back up in the air yet, I rented a car and drove.  My instructions were “take clothes you like, your trip is open ended. You’ll be there as long as they need you”. 

At that point I obviously put my thoughts of buying a house on the back burner, my sole focus was my job.  I worked 90-100 hour weeks tirelessly for the next month, then I was told to come home. 

The troops I was working with took off to Afghanistan in mid October.  I wanted to go too, but got my chance soon thereafter.

 

Opportunistic

The U.S. economy was already in a recession when 9/11 happened.  The Fed had cut interest rates 7 times during 2001, which was why I was tempted to buy a house.  Mortgages were getting cheap. 

Then as the stock market crashed and reeled from the attacks they cut rates two more times to make money more available to consumers, the last being on October 2nd

I was still thousands of miles from home and deep in my work, but I noticed, and it sealed the deal for me. 

“When or if I ever get home, that’s it, I’m going to buy a house”. 

And that’s what I did.  And it was the best single financial decision of my life

I don’t say that because I subscribe to some dogma that everyone should own a house – I don’t.  The pro-renting crowd has some very strong arguments to support their point of view, and it’s all really circumstantial. 

Geography, finances, stage of life, community, and goals all need to play into the decision.  For me the timing was right.  Interest rates were the lowest they had been since 1962 (at around 6%, think about that!), and everything else in my life was ready for a house. 

At the end of October 2001 I found myself buying pizza and beer for my closest buddies who helped me move into my new house.  And man did I choose well.

 

A Bubble?

The Best Financial Decision I've Ever Made

Housing prices in the Washington D.C. metro area started rising fast in 1999, and by late 2001 many thought it was a bubble ready to burst.  That was on my mind, and to be frank I was kind of scared.  Buying any house in the D.C. region would stretch my average-Joe salary more than I was comfortable with. 

But here I am almost 19 years later and my house has more than tripled in value.  To be exact it’s gone up approximately 205%, while inflation has increased about 45% during the same time frame.  For the math challenged that means if my house cost $100,000, it would now sell for $305,000.  Except the real numbers are much larger. 

I do not disclose the price I paid for my house or what it would sell for now because I also do not disclose my net worth.  And it would be easier to figure out the latter if I told the former.  Needless to say, the value of my house constitutes a significant portion of my net worth.  And it will only keep going up…. 

How do I know? 

 

Enter The Behemoth

In November 2018 Amazon announced its second headquarters, or HQ2, to be just a few miles from my house.  Since then my house has appreciated about 28%.  And that’s real data from houses on my street that have sold, with bidding wars. 

Yes the economic downturn and looming recession from this pandemic could dampen things, but history has shown that my house will weather it better than others.  Here’s a chart of housing prices in the D.C. region from the 1990’s to present.

The Best Financial Decision I've Ever Made

 

That big dip from 2006 – 2009 saw prices decrease by about 32%.  During that period my house value went down only about 9%.  And while most other houses are still worth less than the 2006 peak, mine is worth way more. 

Why? 

I purposely bought within a walking distance to a Metro station. 

Washington D.C.’s Metro is one of the best in America (which honestly isn’t saying too much), and houses within a ten minute walk to a D.C. Metro station always hold their value in a downturn.  I knew this going into my purchase because I’m a geographer, and location is what we geographers do 🙂  

Amazon plans to bring about 25,000 employees to their HQ2 who will make an average salary of about $150,000 a year.  Yes, average salary. 

In short, they will flood what is already the wealthiest area in America with a small baseball stadium of super-high income earners, all who need a place to live.  And where Amazon goes, so will tons of new startups and smaller companies, like little remora fish on a shark.

 

Risk, Homework, And Luck

The Best Financial Decision I've Ever MadeSome choose the real estate path to wealth and financial independence.  It wasn’t my path but it is a viable one.  I’ve never been a landlord and really had no interest. 

But I will be one day.  I will not be fully retiring in the Washington D.C. area.  As much as I like it, it’s too crowded, with too much car culture and stress.  I want more peace.

So when I leave this house I will rent it, and currently I could rent it for about three times the cost of my monthly mortgage.  Yes, three times.

I will get a new place in a modest or even low COL area, and be set.  The renters in my D.C. house will be paying my D.C. mortgage, my new mortgage (wherever it is), and I’ll still have about $700 – $1000 left over every month as income. 

All from one house. 

It’s a great position to be in.  

It comes down to taking risk, doing my homework, and having some luck.  I bought into what most thought was a bubble, that was risky.  I did my homework and bought near a metro station.  And Amazon became a juggernaut and decided to plop it’s second headquarters down right near my house.  That’s luck.

So I may not have chosen the real estate path to FI, but I chose a house that will provide me a solid income for the rest of my life.  And it was the best financial decision I’ve ever made. 

 

Subscribe To New Posts Here!

Dave @ Accidental FIRE

I reached financial independence and semi-retired in my mid-40's through hard work, smart living, and investing. This blog chronicles my journey and explores many aspects of personal finance including the psychological and behavioral factors that drive our habits.

You may also like...

34 Responses

  1. Looks like you made a pretty good deal. Without getting into the rent vs buy argument, my experience with home ownership was pretty bad. Scared me off for a good number of years in favor of renting and investing primarily in the stock market. I guess if I see a good enough deal I will do it again but we’ll see.

    Cheers!

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Yeah it can be hit or miss and it’s dependent upon so many variables. Some is luck for sure. Hope you have better luck next time!

  2. That Amazon move certainly sweetened the deal. Do you have any thoughts on where you will land in retirement?

    Max

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      You ain’t kidding, they’re going to make this area even higher cost and already are. It’s good for my home value but scary to consider. As to where I’ll go, I don’t know specifically yet, it’s still gonna be some time before I do. But I will definitely be near mountains. Ideally I’d like a nice smaller town that has a vibrant population of outdoor athletes like Boulder or Asheville NC, but that aren’t Boulder or Asheville 🙂 Those places have jumped the shark, esp Boulder. And I have enough money to have two places (besides my DC home) so I may well get one near the mountains and one near the ocean and just rent them when not using. Lots of possibilities…

  3. Xrayvsn says:

    Congrats on your wise choice. Amazon was an added bonus for sure and I agree that renting that close to a metro station is going to allow you to have a premium over others.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Yeah man I couldn’t have chose better, but like I said I did take some risk. Everyone back then thought it was a bubble ready to burst, just glad I pushed through that risk.

  4. Nathan says:

    Sounds like a home run! I’d like to buy another house right now and rent my current one out but the prices seem way too high to me.

  5. Reminds me of one of the definitions of luck – it’s where preparation meets opportunity. You nailed it. We’re selling our townhouse in Fairfax Co, VA now. We’ve owned it for 20 years. The appreciation in this area is insane. I agree with your assessment of the DMV. Too damn many people. Too much stress. When my wife retires next summer, we’re outa here.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      So you bought your house around when I bought mine, and I don’t even have to know exactly where you are, just knowing that you’re in Fairfax and you bought 20 years ago I know you’re going to do very very well. Congrats to you too!

  6. The Frug says:

    Great post. I’ve always thought of personal homes as great investments. I house hacked 4 homes in Frederick MD. Annapolis MD, Capitol Hill, and Alexandria Virginia. Living with roommates, fixing them up and selling them always covering all of my expenses and getting a solid return while effectively living rent-free. That adds up. Over 15 years. I guess the only mistake I made was flipping these homes. The Capitol Hill home alone appreciated 7X since the initial purchase. Ouch, should have kept that one. But like you I have no interest in being a landlord. Luckily shortly after getting married I purchased a home in Arlington Virginia in 1998 and have experienced similar appreciation through good times and bad. I’ve got about five years left on the mortgage and the only challenge I have is property taxes which are quickly approaching $1000 a month due to the homes value, but I can’t complain about that. I’m also about 2 miles from Amazon HQ. Check out big ERNs Home owners IRR spreadsheet, on the post “That house over there is an investment”. I’d be curious to see what your IRR is. I bet it’s amazing.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      I’ll have to check out big ERN and look at that. I can tell you a story, an old work colleague back in the late 90s bought a house in Capitol Hill in 1998. Back then Capitol Hill was still kind of a ghetto, we all thought he was crazy. He paid something like $120,000 for one of those massive three-story houses. He of course got the last laugh, it’s now worth about 2.6 million. For those not familiar with Washington, Capitol Hill used to be really rough up until around 2000 when it quickly gentrified into one of the richest areas in this area, which is the richest in the country.

      Never sell your Arlington home, it will make you money forever. But you already know that 🙂

  7. 5 AM Joel says:

    Great story and good decision man. Love hearing when home purchases work out well – especially in HCOL areas.

    Oh, and thank you for your service! You’re a hero.
    – Joel

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Thanks Joe! And while I appreciate the sentiment, my time in Afghanistan was mostly spent in front of a computer doing nerdy stuff for the real heroes, the men and women of the United States military and our NATO allies!

  8. i would always say to anyone that no matter what the price appreciation or depreciation you OWN the place. that has some value that is hard to always quantify. we got lucky the same way in that mrs. me bought our place around ’01 before i knew her. they were about giving those big houses away. i would guess the value now about 3-4x what we paid but we’re not leaving until we skip town for good.

    i hear you on those metro stops. our good friends have a little house in boston near an “elite” university. it’s so close you could stand on their stoop and throw a tennis ball and hit the college gymnasium. here’s the bonus. the subway line is being extended to have a station right across the street. they’re gonna score big on that when they peace out.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Sounds like you’re better half bought your house right around when I bought mine. Good to see it’s worked out for you guys too! And a subway line coming to your friend’s house is very much like Amazon’s second headquarters coming near me, pure luck but hey I’ll take it. When I have small things go bad or some bad luck here and there I have to remind myself that I’ve also had a lot of really good luck in life

  9. Sounds like you got in right at the right time! I think with housing, there is SO much involved with timing.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Yep, timing and location. And as I said in the post the timing wasn’t supposed to be right, most people thought it was too risky but I pushed forward. It scared the hell out of me but I’m so glad I did. So I went against the grain on that one. But as for location being that it’s what I do for a living I knew how to choose correctly there 🙂 Thanks for stopping by Tonya!

  10. That’s a great buy. Real estate didn’t work out that well for us because we moved 3 times. We also didn’t get quite the right place. So we didn’t benefit as much from price appreciation. I think it’ll work out in the end once we sell our current home. It’ll be nice to see a lumpsum.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Repeated moves can definitely be a downside, but if you wind up in a home you love it can be worth it I guess.

  11. We just purchased a house about 2 years ago, so I don’t know if it will end up being a good choice or not. However we hope to stay until the end or close to the end. We also really love being able to bigger renovations that we never could have done as renters.

    We almost bought a house years ago (2008ish) just before the housing bubble burst. And we had a liar’s loan, which is basically a huge loan made without income or asset verification. If we had done that, we would have faced foreclosure for sure.
    Scary to think about!

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Wow, had you taken one of those junk loans that would have been really bad. We have to make sure a climate like that never comes to pass again

  12. Great story Dave!

    It used to be you could do no wrong with real estate – plus we all need a place to live anyways.
    I’m also fortunate and purchased my home back in the early 90s.
    Things have changed and it’s no longer a given that home ownership is the best investment.
    It depends on so many factors out of our control and a little luck goes a long way!.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Wow no matter where you are I’m sure your house has done well. Plus as Freddy says there’s certainly something to be said about owning something outright. Cheers Shannon.

  13. Tawcan says:

    A wise decision indeed looking back. When you live in the property yourself, it’s hard to go wrong with real estate investment. We are fortunate to own our house and not renting now so we don’t have to worry about a potential eviction.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      I haven’t heard of many evictions during this crisis, seems that landlords are being lenient and stimulus money is helping… for now.

  14. Prepare2FIRE says:

    One of the things I like about your posts Dave is that you separate actions that you were responsible for vs external influences that allowed you to benefit from your actions. Buying a house was something you were responsible for, the real estate market, Amazon, etc are the external elements that you had no control over. Could have gone the other way but you were fortunate. I was fortunate too when we purchased our home in the late 90’s. It’s worth multiples of the cost now, but not because I was a real estate guru. We wanted a house for our home and are still happy with that decision.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      I appreciate that compliment, I always try to be honest and clear in how things went down. I also am no real estate guru, I just went with my gut. My gut told me “now is the time”. My gut isn’t always right, but it was that time and I’m grateful!

  15. Mr. Fate says:

    Nice article Dave and near identical story here. Bought my place in So Cal at about the same time and had it triple as well. I sold it and got back the 20% down payment and every P&I payment for 18 years and far more beyond that. The “more”, one it’s own was enough to fund our new home build here in WA. Basically, that one house purchase in 2002 has/will allow me to live for free in beautiful homes my entire adult life. And for that reason, it is also, the best financial decision I’ve ever made.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Wow sounds like you scored too. For me it’s going to be best to keep it when I leave and rent as the value of the house and amount of rent I can charge will keep going up with the new Amazon development. If I sold the lump sum would be nice, but the huge stream of regular income will be nice too.

  16. I don’t see you renting your house long term. I would see 6 month windows of rental to do big trips in the alpine somewhere or heck maybe a cross country bike ride if our borders remain closed. I thought about selling our home and downsizing but we live 1 block from the ocean and I would never be able to buy real estate like this ever again for the price we paid. Like you we will be holding loooooonggg term on this one.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Oh trust me I’ll never sell the house because it will only keep appreciating, and faster than other in the area. The D.C. area will likely always be the richest in America as long as I’m alive and have the strongest job market simply because of government jobs and the contractors who depend on them.

      But those big alpine trips will keep happening, and hopefully I’ll live closer to them 🙂 Wow, 1 block from the ocean, that is sweet!

  17. Mr. Tako says:

    Incredible financial decision Dave! I’ve hear stories of these kinds of deals were someone got rich off just one property, but you’re the first that I’ve really *known* (at least in the virtual sense) that it’s happened to.

    Would you attribute this success to skill, luck, or a combination of both?

    I hear you on the peace and quiet though. I’d love to live some place a little cheaper, more laid back, and a lot less crowded. That’s hard to find though, without giving up a whole lot of important things (like good schools, diversity, etc). I’ve been hunting for a couple years already!

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Thanks Tako, to be clear my house alone doesn’t make me FI, but it is a significant part of my net worth and would constitute more money than 95% of Americans have to their name. I attribute it to both skill and luck, the skill part being the choice to be near a metro which was done by evaluating data, and the luck being mostly the Amazon decision.

Drop Me A Comment - What's On Your Mind?

Verified by MonsterInsights