Comparing Median Incomes And Home Values Across America
Regular readers know I’m always on the hunt for great mapping tools that show various aspects of finance in a geographic way. I even have an entire page dedicated to geoarbitrage resources and tools to help you find a better place to live based on any number of factors related to money or quality of life.
I post annually about the median household income in America when the data come out in the fall. If you want to geek out further I have a post highlighting a more detailed tool that shows the highest median household income in your area by age group. And I’ve posted about the income gap to affordable housing, and the state of housing.
Bottom line – how much you make and how much a house costs are probably the two main factors that rise to the top in choosing a place to live. Not every time, but on average I’d say they’re near the top in most circumstances.
This cool new mapping site from my friends at ESRI conflates those two very important factors – median household income and median home value.
The Map
When you open the map you should see this. (*Note – ESRI makes more sophisticated mapping sites that aren’t always optimized for phones. I highly suggest using this site on a full computer or at least a tablet.)
It may appear their data is aggregated at only a very large county level but they have incorporated scale-dependent views (I’m using dorky cartographer terms here). If you zoom in to an area of interest you’ll notice the data are actually pretty detailed.
I live near Washington D.C., and here’s what that looks like.
Under the “Content” tab on the left you’ll notice they have the data aggregated at 5 different levels:
- Country
- State
- County
- Zip Code
- Tract
- Block Group
The “Country” and “State” layers have no data and are useless at that scale anyway, it’s the others that have the real data of interest. “Tract” is a Census Tract, and “Block” is a sub-division of Census Tracts at a finer level. If you’re interested at all in these you can read how they delineate them here.
Just leave all the layers checked on because they are all “scale dependent”, meaning the best layer will display depending on how far you zoom in.
All Those Colors
The key to using this map is to understand the color coding scheme. Click the “Legend” tab on the left and you will see this:
In typical ESRI fashion they got cartographically creative with their legend display. It may look confusing but it’s actually simple. On the color diamond, colors more to the left indicate higher median house values, but lower median incomes. Colors to the right indicate higher median household incomes and lower median home values. Colors toward the top are high in both, and of course colors on the bottom are low in both.
So, if I were moving to another part of the country, were still working, and wanted to buy a house and settle down, what would I look for? Well, I’d want an area with higher median household incomes, but lower median home values. In short, a place where I would tend to earn more but where homes are cheaper.
On the map legend those areas are on the right side, the three shades of blue. The cyan-colored blue on the far right might just be the sweet spot. But if you start fishing around you’ll notice those areas are hard to find, surprise surprise!
Because when folks earn more they naturally drive home values up, thats how markets work. But those places are out there. Having grown up in Baltimore I’m very familiar with Southern Pennsylvania, and I figured there would be some near Harrisburg, the PA capitol. Housing is notoriously cheap in some areas of PA. I was correct!
Here’s an area south of Harrisburg that has quite a few of those Census Tracts:
Also notice that you can click on an area and you’ll get a simple pop-up showing the median home value and median household income.
In the case shown above the median household income is $82,417 – well above the U.S. median of $63,000, and the median home value is $191,423. That’s a pretty reasonable home price if you’re making 82 grand. I live in an area with virtually no homes priced below $400,000, so the thought of being able to buy a home for $191,000 doesn’t make sense to me, and actually makes my head explode.
Geoarbitrage
So there you have it financial warriors, a great tool that shows two huge factors in deciding where to live – how much you can make and how much a home costs.
I post lots of tools like this that show various aspects of money and finance from a location perspective. If you’re considering Geoarbitrage in the United States this mapping tool can help you gauge income levels by age to help tune you in on trends and areas you might not be aware of.
Also be sure to check out my Geoarbitrage Resources Page that has tons of great tools to help you find your perfect location.
I hope you find these resources handy and I will continue to expose valuable tools that can help when deciding on a geoarbitrage strategy.
Great tools. I made big city wages in a rural location my entire career. Consequently almost none of my net worth is tied up in my paid for $190,000 4 bedroom 4 bathroom 3,000 sq ft house on two acres. My taxes and insurance total $200 a month. No HOA. Living is very inexpensive here.
Wow, you just made my head explode again… to be honest I have no interest in a 4BR 4 Bath house of that size, but the fact that it’s $190k is insane. That means a modest house more my size would likley be under $100k in your area, with property. Bonkers.
i’m pretty familiar with some low housing cost areas having grown up in the boondocks. it’s nice to know that for 90-100 grand you can have a house less than 30 minutes from saratoga springs. i suppose you have to be from there and have friends to appreciate some of these joints. probably if i were an outsider with none of those things i would think it sucked. my old company had a hard time finding a quality manager who was well paid because people didn’t want to live there. i’m glad we don’t need to consider the income side much longer and can just focus on a house where we want to live.
Again you guys are killing me, full houses for $100 grand. There are literally hipsters in D.C. who pay that much for a parking spot to add on to their $800,000 studio condo.
That’s an interesting map. We’ve always lived in a high cost area. Hopefully, we can move somewhere cheaper after our son is done with school.
I’m sure you’ll find a nice place to settle that meets you cost tolerance Joe. Don’t forget to use my geoarbitrage tools to help 🙂
Fun tool to browse around nearby with. We’re smack-dab in the middle of two extremes: $200k median income on one side with $1m+ houses and $16k median income on the other side (students!).
Ha, $16k median income. My business might make that much this year – I could move there!
Neat tool Dave! I spend a bunch of time just looking around at other areas, but as you noticed those ‘blue’ areas are hard to find!
Yeah I think I need to move to a “blue zone”
Thanks for sharing this map. I know all too well about living in HCOL areas since I’m living in Toronto
I’ve heard about the craziness of Toronto real estate prices. I used to go to your city for work sometimes back in the day, really love it!
Too bad this tool doesn’t show Canadian cities, they’d need new colours for some of our real estate values. Love the tool thought, thanks for sharing it.
Yeah DC commented about Toronto as well.. thanks for stopping by!
Any idea how to get to the underlying data the powers the map? If at all?
ESRI didn’t do a good job of metadata and sourcing on this one. I’d be 99% certain they got the income data from the Census Bureau, who works with the Bureau of Labor Statistics to get it. Government websites suck, they have too much data and it’s poorly organized. You should be able to find it here.
Be aware that 2018 is the latest income data released. They release the official figures in September each year for the previous year, so the 2018 data was released in Sept 2019.
As for the home value data, not sure of that one. My guess is they’re partnering with Redfin or Zillow and possibly mixing it or averaging it with government data. If you pay for an ESRI subscription to their full services you can probably download the data.
I looked up my neighborhood (light yellow):
Median home value: $138,462
Median household income: $37,794
We do have more of those grey blue blocks near us along with several large green blocks but much of the city is either light yellow or grey. A few white (low cost homes with low income)
If you go up 8 blocks to a grey block:
Median home value: $272,143
Median household income: $61,245
and 4 blocks SW to the grey blue:
Median home value: $295,745
Median household income: $88,887
My city is known for having affordable housing but along with that we also have a lot of low income jobs too. Of course you don’t have to live in a bright blue block, that just means your neighbors also paid less for their home while making good wages. You can live in a yellow or white block – your neighbors will probably make/have less money than you.
Wow that’s a ton of diversity in numbers. A house for $138 seems crazy to me, but on a 37k salary that’d still be hard I guess.