The Costs Of Long Term Care By State
None of us will get out of here alive. Sorry for the unfortunate truth bomb. And although lifespan in general in America has gone up over the years with some recent declines, healthspan, or the number of years a person can expect to live free of chronic disease and in relatively good health, has not.
So Americans are increasingly in need of long term care or nursing home care at earlier ages due to the epidemics of lifestyle related chronic disease. If you haven’t faced these issues yet, you’re likely to in the future for either yourself or a loved one. And that means long term care.
What is long term care? Healthcare.gov defines it thusly:
Services that include medical and non-medical care provided to people who are unable to perform basic activities of daily living such as dressing or bathing. Long-term supports and services can be provided at home, in the community, in assisted living or in nursing homes. Individuals may need long-term supports and services at any age.
Long term care is expensive. Most importantly, long term care is not healthcare and thus is not paid for by health insurance. Medicare in some cases will cover short stays in a nursing home under strict conditions, but in general your health insurance will not help you with long term care.
Medicaid will cover long term care but only if the patient has a very low income and $2,000 of assets or less beyond their primary home.
How expensive is long term care and how much does it vary across the nation? I haven’t done a mapping post in a while, but I’m here at your service to show the goods.
Different Types
There are different types of long term care and the lines between them can be easily blurred. I have good and recent cost data broken down by state from the American Council On Aging and Long Term Care Insurance Partner and they break long term care into 4 main categories:
- Home Care Providers
- Adult Day Health Care Facilities
- Assisted Living Facilities
- Nursing Homes
There are others out there such as independent living facilities and hospice care. But let’s look at the cost data for the 4 categories defined above.
Home Health Care
Medicare.gov defines home health care thusly:
Home health care is a wide range of health care services that can be given in your home for an illness or injury. Home health care is usually less expensive, more convenient, and just as effective as care you get in a hospital or skilled nursing facility (SNF).
Here is the breakdown of the monthly costs of home health care by state (click on map for larger version):
The three most expensive states are:
- Minnesota $6,292
- Washington $6,031
- Rhode Island $5,911
The three least expensive states are:
- Louisiana $3,241
- Alabama $3,432
- Mississippi & West Virginia (tied) $3,537
Adult Day Care
Eldercare.acl.gov defines adult day care as:
Adult Day Care Centers are designed to provide care and companionship for older adults who need assistance or supervision during the day. Programs offer relief to family members and caregivers, allowing them to go to work, handle personal business, or just relax while knowing their relative is well cared for and safe.
You may see adult day care referred to as “adult day health care”, or “adult day services”, or “senior day care” among other terms.
Here is the breakdown of the monthly costs of adult day care by state (click on map for larger version):
The three most expensive states are:
- Maine $3,467
- Wyoming $3,250
- Alaska $3,055
The three least expensive states are:
- Alabama $655
- Texas $698
- North Carolina $1,278
Assisted Living
WebMD defines assisted living as:
Assisted living is a type of housing designed for people who need various levels of medical and personal care. Living spaces can be individual rooms, apartments, or shared quarters. The facilities generally provide a home-like setting and are physically designed to promote the resident’s independence. Services are offered to assist residents with daily living.
Here is the breakdown of the monthly costs of assisted living by state (click on map for larger version):
The three most expensive states are:
- Delaware $6,690
- New Jersey & New Hampshire (tied) $6,650
- Alaska $6,633
The three least expensive states are:
- Missouri $3,000
- Alabama $3,150
- Utah $3,400
Nursing Home
The first thing to know about nursing homes is that there is something called NHLOC, which stands for “Nursing Home Level Of Care”. Sounds like a good thing and that there seems to be a standard.
Nope. As Medicaid’s help section says:
Because the federal government doesn’t universally define the criteria for a nursing home level of care, each state must set its own definition. Specific rules and approved assessment tools vary depending on where you live, and states may use different ranking systems for determining the appropriate level of care for an individual.
One would think that since Medicaid is often used to pay for a nursing home and that Medicaid is one of the Federal Government’s welfare programs that the Feds would come to a universal criteria for NHLOC. But maybe that makes too much sense. Regardless a more general definition of a nursing home is this provided by Medcine.Net.
A residential facility for people with chronic illness or disability, particularly older people who have mobility and eating problems. Also known as a convalescent home and long-term care facility.
Here is the breakdown of the monthly costs of a nursing home with a semi-private room (click on map for larger version):
The three most expensive states are:
- Alaska $37,413 (yes that’s monthly, and yes I checked other sources to verify)
- Connecticut $12,927
- Massachusetts $12,623
The three least expensive states are:
- Texas $5,019
- Missouri $5,080
- Oklahoma $5,323
And here is the breakdown of the monthly costs of a nursing home with a private room (click on map for larger version):
The three most expensive states are:
- Alaska $36,378
- Connecticut $13,992
- Hawaii $13,802
The three least expensive states are:
- Missouri $5,749
- Oklahoma $5,779
- Louisiana $5,840
Geography matters. The yearly cost difference of a nursing home with a private room between Alaska ($436,536) and Missouri ($68,988) is $367,548.
Like me you might be wondering why nursing homes in Alaska cost such an exorbitant amount. I found this slightly dated article about the issue but it doesn’t provide much insight except to state that Alaska is an expensive state. Since this blog reaches literally dozens of people (numerous dozens!) please chime in below if you have specific knowledge of the issue.
Geoarbitrage
So there you have it financial warriors, some super-duper maps that show the average monthly costs of different kinds of long term care in America.
I do lots of posts like this that show various aspects of money and finance from a location perspective. So you’re considering Geoarbitrage in the United States be sure to check out my Geoarbitrage Resources Page which has tons of great tools to help you find your perfect location.
I hope you find these resources handy and I will continue to expose valuable tools that can help when deciding on a geoarbitrage strategy.
In order to combat these high cost, would saving as much as possible in an HSA be a way to help?
Thanks for all the research!
I believe HSA money can only be used for healthcare costs, and as mentioned in the post long term care is not covered by health insurance. So my hunch is no, but hopefully a more informed person can chime in
Per IRS Publications 969 (https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p969.pdf) and 502 (https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p502.pdf): Nursing Home
You can include in medical expenses the cost of medical care in a nursing home, home for the aged, or similar institution, for yourself, your spouse, or your dependents. This includes the cost of meals and lodging in the home if a principal reason for being there is to get medical care.
Don’t include the cost of meals and lodging if the reason for being in the home is personal. You can, however, include in medical expenses the part of the cost that is for medical or nursing care.
There is also a section for Long Term Care in Pub 502.
readers to the rescue – thanks Lisa!
While I try not to think about it, it’s great to have a better understanding of the associated costs. Wow! Odd that WA is more than CA, but likely a function of economies of scale. Anyway, I guess the price of zero state income tax here in WA is a higher than normative cost for long-term care. Also, very interesting about the “Healthspan” concept. I’m going to dig deeper on that data.
Healthspan in America is horrible and declining rapidly, mainly due to the obesity epidemic. We’re rapidly headed toward a 50% obesity rate and it scares me more than anything else going on
the part of all this that really grinds my gears is the high cost of “care” but most of the workers get paid very little. same as daycare workers and those costs are astronomical too. where the hell is all the money going? my guess is towards compliance of regulations that come in a 3 foot thick binder and insurance coverage. in our lawsuit happy country it’s a mess. welcome to the united states of insurance. i woke up in a good mood until i started thinking about the subject.
i think costs are more reasonable in other countries, just a hunch.
Very true dude, I have more experience in nursing homes than I wish I had and I can say that those workers do amazingly hard work that’s emotionally tough and they mostly do it with empathy. And I can’t speak for what they’re paid but yeah, I’m guessing not too much. Sorry to ruin your day, haha, but maybe blame it on the lawyers.
Things are rarely due to one factor but our legal system certainly plays a role.
Keeping in mind that there’s bias in every POV, here’s an article I found interesting simply because it helps describe the breadth of the mess and opacity of the finances (note, it was written when the Covid impacts to Nursing Homes was all over the news)
https://www.aarp.org/caregiving/health/info-2020/covid-19-nursing-homes-failing-business-model.html
Oh yeah it’s a complex issue, as is all of healthcare. Thx for the link, interesting read
Great post! Many people avoid talking about uncomfortable long term care decisions until a dire situation arises and they’re short on time or money (or both). This is a gentle reminder tto plan ahead and ensure you’re prepared no matter what State you live in and your income level. It’s also imperative to have a POA and an up to date Will prepared by a competent lawyer to help prevent elder abuse or estate issues. (And no, I’m not a lawyer lol!)
I’m going through it now with my family, tough decisions need to be made and we wish we had planned more
Wow, never would have guessed that I lived in one of the states with the most expensive long term care! Good information Dave! Most people don’t think about these costs when they’re pre-retirement age. It’s only when you get old do these costs become real.
Recently Washington state mandated a long-term care insurance program for anyone in the state, and it was a total nightmare. Many people chose to opt for private insurance, because the state plan was so bad.
It seems pretty hard to get this right in a way that’s equitable and fair to all. Kind of a “damned if you do, and damned if you don’t” kind of situation.
Mandatory long term care seems like a slippery slope to me but you’ll have to see how it plays out. To your point though, yes, it’s really hard to get it right. And as Americans keep getting more obese and have the associated chronic diseases that come from that it’s only going to get worse
Thanks for a very helpful post on the realities of costs many of us will face as we age. There’s a reason they call the retirement spending curve a “Smile”, it will definitely go up near the end. Best to plan for it rather than just pretend it isn’t going to happen. #FaceReality
The stoic mindset means facing reality as it is, not as you wish it to be
Here’s a topic I haven’t thought much about when it comes to financial ramifications. I think it’s the kind of thing you don’t think about until you have to. Crazy how much variance there is. Not sure if you’ve read the book Being Mortal, but it’s an excellent look at handling end-of-life care for loved ones.
For most of us I think it’ll be needed for parents or family members before ourselves. That’s where I’m at
Due to unplanned circumstances my friend needed to get her mom into a care setting. Because another relative had been in the facility, they worked with her, but it wasn’t easy. Most of the time a bed becomes free is due to someone getting worse or passing away.
Some of the issues I’m seeing with friends and their parents, or my parent’s friends is not a lack of wishing they could provide care for their parent or spouse, but that diseases like dementia can be too severe for home care. Other times the variety of medical conditions is too much for the family member as they have their own stuff going on. There’s one person who cares for her grand children while her daughter works, and shares care of her aging mother.
Another consideration is difficult relationships. Some people don’t have great relationships with their parents and to ask for a level of care, is just too much.
Thank you for sharing the statistics.
You’ve brought up so many things here that have to be considered and that hammer home how hard this can be. And everyone’s journey and story will be different. I’m dealing with a few of these myself.
That’s one of the reasons why my mom moved back to Thailand in 2018. The cost of long term care is so high in the US.
Now, we are looking for a good local nursing home for her in Chiang Mai. A pretty good one will cost about $1,000 per month for a shared room. There are more expensive places geared for foreigners too. Those are more like resorts and cost $3,000 to $4,000/month.
At that stage of dementia, I don’t think it makes much of a difference. As long as the care is good. I don’t know…
These are tough choices Joe, you’re doing the best you can. And while it might sound cruel to say, I agree that once the mental state of someone is compromised enough it doesn’t matter as much how pretty the room is of the facility. My grandma had full-on Alzheimer’s and didn’t know who she even was. The nursing home she was in (in Baltimore) was pretty crappy and smelled bad, but she was actually laughing most days. Her Alzheimer’s was such that she joked and laughed a lot and once thought I was Frank Sinatra when I visited. So we didn’t feel as bad about having her there. But I would have never let her stay there if her mental state was good.