Like Financial Independence There’s More Than One Way To Get In Shape
Did you make a new year’s resolution to get in shape in 2019? Maybe get a new gym membership and really start taking your health seriously? Well, we’re two weeks into the new year, how’s it going so far?
The Mad Fientist put out a podcast about working out in December last year which I thought was really great. His episodes are always great and you should check him out if he’s not on your podcast list.
However, like all advice, it’s not going to hit the sweet spot for everyone, and that’s okay. Nothing does.
So I want to give my take on working out and getting fit, since what worked for me and what resonates with me is a bit different than the advice given in that podcast. As a reminder, I’m a guy who grew up as a fat kid and lost 60 pounds as an adult. So I feel I have some credibility in the fact that at least I totally transformed my own body. That in turn transformed my entire life.
The focus of the advice in the MF podcast was solely about lifting weights, in a gym. To be clear upfront – everything the guest said in the podcast is true! Lifting weights is an incredibly efficient way to get in shape, lose weight, and get stronger and healthier.
But it’s not for everyone. Why?
- What if you don’t like lifting weights?
- What if you don’t like exercising inside and would rather be outdoors?
- What if you don’t want to pay money every month to exercise?
- What if you’re very overweight and are conscious and intimidated of being looked at or judged by fit people in a gym?
Again, I’m not saying it wasn’t a good podcast. I love his stuff and I think the message in the podcast could work for a large segment of the population very well. I do lift weights, sometimes.
But here’s the thing, you don’t have to pay a monthly membership fee to a gym to work out or to get in shape. The very reason that a lot of people say they want to go to the gym – to be motivated by others – is the same reason tons of other people stay away.
Because they feel like they’re going to be ashamed to be around healthy people, or will be ridiculed. Because they’re overweight, or feel unattractive. To these people gyms are intimidating and create anxiety.
Plus, gyms are expensive. The average gym membership costs between $40 and $50 a month. That doesn’t include the annual fee. Most people pay about $800 a year total. That’s crazy.
On top of all of that, you probably have to drive or take time to get to a gym, creating yet another hurdle to prevent you from working out.
For me personally, gyms are indoors and thus confining. They play horrendously bad music, loudly. They have machines with other people’s sweat on them, and they smell.
I just don’t like any of that. I like working out outside, which means running, cycling, climbing, and even doing my plyometrics and weightlifting out on my patio.
Bottom line – you don’t have to go to a gym and pay all that money to get in shape.
Make It Your Lifestyle, Not A Task To Do
The key thing is to do something that you will continue doing. Which means do something that you like. My best advice in one sentence is:
Find a way to make a strenuous fitness activity part of your lifestyle and your social circle.
If you don’t like any type of exercise, do the stuff that you hate the least. Pretending that you’re going to continue going to a gym if you loathe gyms is setting your self up for another failed resolution.
Likewise, pretending that your going to continue riding a bike if you’re not jazzed on bikes is also probably a bad idea. Health and fitness need to be part of your life, so your main job is to figure out what activities and environment can fit in your life – and stay in your life.
That latter part is the key. If your fitness activity doesn’t stay a core part of your life you’ll just drift back to your old, unhealthy self.
It’s the same reason diets don’t work. Inherent in the word “diet” is the assumption that it’s a temporary change to lose weight.
Nada, won’t work. You need to permanently change the way you eat.
And remember that all movement helps and counts. So make walking or biking your lifestyle when feasible, instead of using a car. Make stairs your lifestyle, not elevators. Make a rake, not a leaf-blower, your lifestyle.
Unless you have 10 acres of course.
We’re Not All Made Of The Same Stuff
Probably the main reason I don’t like lifting weights and gravitated towards endurance activities is because I have mostly slow twitch muscles. This means I can lift and lift and I don’t really bulk up much. Lifting, however, still helps boost my metabolism and has tremendous benefits for me. So I still do it once a week.
But I found out in my 30’s that my muscles are really good at going the distance, aka slow twitch. I’m talking very long outings at a strenuous level. A perfect fit for running, cycling, and mountaineering. Being strong does not necessarily mean you are “fit”, and vice-versa.
I’ve been on quite a few mountain climbing trips where the bulky weight lifting guys didn’t last past the first 2 hours up the mountain, with 6 hours left to go. They were wiped and had to turn around, while I wasn’t even breathing hard. I’m not trying to be boastful in saying that, they were far more muscular than me. But they were fast twitch muscle guys.
I was jealous of their biceps, and they were jealous of my resting heart rate.
If you only lift weights you’re not training your heart to work out for longer periods of time.
That doesn’t mean you can’t get healthy lifting weights though!! If you don’t seek to do hobbies or things that require extended periods of effort like hiking or climbing and do them at a relatively high level, then that’s okay. Lifting weights to stay healthy is probably all you need.
I like to climb big mountains. Lifting weights is not enough to get me (more accurately my heart) to the fitness needed to do that.
How It Became My Lifestyle
How did outdoor endurance activities become my lifestyle, and what can you take away from my experience?
I chose endurance sports as my lifestyle fitness activity because:
- My body is mostly slow twitch muscles so I’m better suited for them.
- I’m pretty good at them.
- Once I noticed that I was pretty good at them, I started liking them.
And remember – you have to like the activities you use to stay healthy, or you won’t stick with them.
Next thing you know I was going on group runs and bike rides with 30 or 40 people and I started gaining a big social circle around these activities. Now a large portion of my closest friends also pursue these activities. And they kick my ass and motivate me on a daily basis.
I won’t dare miss the big 50 mile ride on Sunday when I know some of my best friends are going to be there. Part of it is accountability, but also, who doesn’t want to see their friends? It gives me a much easier reason to show up.
Poof, just like that these healthy activities became a core part of my life. They’re not things I do, they’re who I am and a big part of of my social life.
Big difference. Going back to the comment about dieting, I can say that endurance activities are not my diet, they’re the way I eat.
The Mad Fientist podcast was very gym-centric and “bulk-up” centric. And it’s a proven way to get healthy and supercharge your metabolism. It’s just not the way that I could make my lifestyle.
All of those things I just wrote about my journey could hold true for you and for lifting weights in a gym. Different strokes for different folks.
You might find that you’re a really good power-lifter and take to it more. Maybe you’ll set new dead lift PR’s every few months. Next thing you know you establish a great group of lifting friends who become part of your social circle. That’s where the magic happens and the “lifestyle” part kicks in!
If that’s you then my best advice is run with it – pay the gym membership. If there’s anything worth spending $800 a year on it’s your health. It’ll be totally worth it!!
We in the financial independence community like to say personal finance is called that for a reason – because it is personal. What works for others might not work for you. My goal with this post was to show that you don’t have to follow one prescribed method to get healthier and in better shape.
Find a way to make a strenuous fitness activity part of your lifestyle and your social circle. Do this and you will win the game.
Getting you @$$ moving is just so important, it really enhances many aspects of your life.
We got a dog, also get’s me out of the house more often now 😉
Dogs are a great way to get out moving!
Wow Dave. Did not know you were a heavier kid (like me) in school. You certainly have done a major transformation from that point. I lost 50 lbs in college when I started jogging around 4 miles a day and eating right. Maintained that weight until starting putting it on when I was unhappy in marriage. About a year after my divorce I decided to reclaim my old life back and started working out. My method of choice is the elliptical which I have in my house. Lower impact for me and I watch TV while I work out so knock out 2 things at once. I ended up losing about 40 lbs since divorce and kept it off for 7 years(although this past fall was tough and put on 10 lbs which I am now trying to work off).
CONGRATS to you too for losing that weight. As a doc you know how unhealthy it is to be overweight or obese. But modern life makes it SO HARD to stay healthy. It’s a struggle.
Exercise has always been a struggle for me just because I don’t get motivated by it. So unfortunately, it’s always been the first thing I cut when I don’t have time.
I’m still trying to get used to this early retirement stuff, but my wife and I have been going to the exercise room at our apartment complex pretty routinely over the past couple of weeks. I hope we can stick with it because, like you said, it needs to be a lifestyle change for it to work.
I used to love playing racquetball because it was such a good cardio workout while still having fun. However, we don’t have a lot of around here anymore. I noticed a couple places near where we’re planning to live in Panama that have them though, so hopefully we can get going on that again once there… you up for a game? 😉
— Jim
I am! And I’ve never played racquetball, but I’m a decent tennis player, so maybe I have a bit of a head start. Now you have TIME, the biggest ingredient, go after it dude!
you won this one, dave. we’re all going to like one thing more than another. i really miss the social aspect of running and most of my good runner friends are retired or live far away. i never liked the thought of paying money to go and work out either. i used college gyms in winter when i was a student and the work gym right now because of winter and i can do it during the work day. that feels like a win every time. once my running friends started dropping off around age 25 or 30 i found a group in the park who were my fitness level so i went on a couple of workouts with them but they bored me. i had to kick ’em to the curb. i checked my resting heart rate while taking my blood pressure last month and it was 49. i was surprised that a person can have a huge gut like mine and still be somewhat fit. it don’t add up!
Damn dude, 49 is a great heart rate, esp in that you haven’t been hitting it hard lately. If you really started getting back in you could probably go for low 40’s. I had mine down to 43 at one point, that’s my best. You know how it is, you just feel so much better when you’re heart isn’t chuggin like a steam engine all the time to just exist.
The parking lot of any gym in January is enough to keep most people away, and I DO go to the gym! My pet peeve in life is looking for parking when parking is tough. Anyway, the answer to the question of “what workout is best,” is “the one that you do.” Same for diet. It doesn’t matter if it’s keto or paleo or Mediterranean, if you do it and you’re healthy, it’s working. I have the opposite of you. I have fast twitch muscles. I hate distance but love speed and height. I’ve very well suited for beach volleyball…if only I was’t 5’4. 🙁
I figured you were fast twitch as a volleyball player! I’m 6’4″, so I’m decent at volleyball but only because my height makes up for my lack of a good vertical jump. Volleyball is an awesome way to stay in shape and you can do it outside!
Tonya are you the person at the gym who drives around the parking lot several times looking for the closest parking spot?! My wife does that, I always giggle and tell her she’s doing it wrong haha. I always park far away and get a head start on my warmup, as well as the added benefit of no door dings and a good amount of risk mitigation in one of life’s most common accident locations…the dreaded parking lot.
Just wondering, how are you tracking all the miles from your activites? I am just starting to ride my bike a lot and was wondering how I can keep track of the miles. Thanks!
I use Strava. There’s other good options like MapMyRun/Ride, or Garmin Connect. Most let you make graphs and charts of your data so you can dork out and analyze your workouts.
“You need to permanently change the way you eat. “
Exactly!
People think to start a diet to lose 5kg…they lose them ..they go back to the same habits…and they gain 10kg….
Exactly… another one that drives me nuts is the “I need to lose 15 pounds before my wedding to fit in my tux”. With the assumption of course that they’ll just gain it back right after the wedding.
Taiko drumming gives us great exercise and a social circle and we practice Tai Chi for nearly an hour every day. But these are just not enough. We both totally enjoy hiking in the Sierras, but realistically we just don’t get there often enough to stay in shape to the mountains. Where we live is flat.
I’ve been on a brainstorming activity to try out new things. We did a Rock Climbing class on Saturday with REI. OMG, that is hard on your fingers! I started bleeding on my second try up that crazy limestone wall, but wow, what an amazing experience. I was not afraid of the rope catching me and being with the group outside was fun. Yet, just like the flatness of Stockton, this is hard to pursue with regularity. So the search goes on. I’ve been thinking of trying the gym, but in the past it was a turn-off to me, being indoor, sweat filled, and a singles meeting place. But now that we’re retired (free!) we can go midday and it might be better. Plus I love to swim and have no other option except cold lakes!
BTW, we went to see Free Solo on IMAX the next day after the Rock Climbing class. Whoa! If nothing else, it really enhanced our appreciation and inspired the heck out of us. Thanks for being the reason we even tried these things.
Glad you went and had a great time Susan! Yes, climbing can be tough on the fingers, but if you do it enough it’s like anything else, you’ll get tougher skin in the right places.
Swimming is amazing exercise, and even though it usually entails paying a fee to belong to a pool it’s probably worth it.
As for Free Solo, crazy huh? Even though you know he doesn’t fall and die it’s SCARY as crap to watch! The guy is from another planet.
“It’s the same reason diets don’t work. Inherent in the word “diet” is the assumption that it’s a temporary change to lose weight.”
Precisely! I hear so often that people are “going on a diet,” which implies its eventual failure. Diets don’t work; established good habits work. Too often people aren’t committed to good habits, whether health or finance related and they get upset when they don’t achieve their desired results. But habits can be hard to change.
Great job on losing all the weight! Hopefully, that means you’ll never be one of my patients! 😉
No offense Katie, but I hope to never be one of your patients 🙂
Great post – I’m doing exactly the same in my first year of retirement in a part of the country that’s conducive to outdoor activities. Between hiking, running, Spin classes, mountain biking and kayaking, I’m weaving as many outdoor fitness activities as possible into my daily lifestyle. Along the way, I’m making new friends. A great way to live life .
You’re doing what I’ll eventually do when I fully retire, live in the mountains. I love the mountains, can’t get enough. Saw your FB posts, you’re starting out STRONG this year on fitness, keep at it man!
This is great! Reminds me of the Will Gadd video “move” . Same idea. It doesn’t matter what you do as long as you do it. As you said, you’re more likely to do something if it’s fun, so find something you enjoy!
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xCpowcXopKE
🎥 Arc’teryx – MOVE – YouTube
HA – I posted about that video a year ago – https://accidentalfire.com/2018/02/27/isaac-newton-linked-finances/
I still watch it all the time to get fired up. And guess what, I’m off to go ice climbing in 3 days, so I’ll be watching it more!
Late last year I tipped the scale at over 265 pounds. I’d been heavier only once in my life, in my late 20s, when I was around 275 pounds. I lost 80 pounds going to a gym (free for a university employee) and commuting by bicycle.
This time around, I do not have a bikable commute, and I do not have a free gym membership. Knowing that the motivation and environment of the gym works for me, I did go ahead and justify the expense for a membership. Without the bicycle commute, though, I knew that my results would not be as easily – or as quickly – achieved. I’m looking into different types of diets, and seriously working on cutting out my carbs anyway. I hope that the diet + exercise combination can get me back to a better state of health. I’ve been exercising at least 3 days a week since the first week in November – usually 5-6 days a week, to be honest. So far I’ve lost 15 pounds.
I found a way that works for me once before, hopefully, I find another route up the mountain. Personal finance is so much easier for me.
It’s hard Chris, I’m with ya. It seems that everything about modern life in America is designed to make us unhealthy. Sedentary jobs, car dependent environments, technology everywhere that encourages us to sit, crappy food everywhere, and stressful jobs. I blog about health and fitness quite a bit, and I hope it doesn’t come off that I have it all figured out. It’s a daily struggle for me too. The pull to fall victim to eating too much and not getting in that workout when you’re tired – those are STRONG pulls.
You got this dude, 15 lbs is a great start. Keep it going. Celebrate your victories along the way but don’t lose sight of the goal.
Just want to drop a quick plug for a business based out of my home state, Planet Fitness memberships can be had for as little as $10/month! They also do a pretty good job of marketing to the non-hardcore gym crowd, which is a kindness but also a great business/marketing model. I do like having the gym option, mostly because I work from home and it gives me a reason to get out of the house and break up the workday. Otherwise, all things being equal, I am a firm believer that the world’s best gym is right outside your door and it is 100% free!
I was going to mention Planet Fitness, they’ve clearly shown there’s a huge market out there of folks who are intimidated by traditional gyms and who have “gym anxiety”.
Thanks for stopping by Mike and get outside today!
Walking briskly is my thing, but finding a good place to walk near our new home has been a challenge. We had access to greenway trails at our old home and by Mr. Groovy’s parents. We settled for a track around a community soft ball field which is lacking in scenery but gets the job done. I supplement with free weights and Mr. G does his home garage/gym workout with rings.
Maybe you need to build your own track or trails at the Groovy ranch. You guys also get good exercise picking up trash!
I totally agree. It doesn’t matter which you do, just do something. And if it is a chore, it i shard to form the habit. Working out is something my wife and I do together. It is a good chance for us to have something that is just ours.
Working out with a partner is the way to go, accountability matters
Me like this post so much I got a CMLT!!!
Ha!
“Six pack abs are made in the kitchen, not the gym.”
You’re right, the key to getting fit is to do things that you enjoy. HOWEVER, I think you anybody can reframe and re-train their mind to enjoy anything.
I was a fat kid too. My parents called me husky and hefty, though. I thought I was doomed to have love handles my entire life. That perception of myself changed a few years ago when I changed my diet!
Wow, having met you I would never have thought you were heavy Doc. There was actually a clothing size called “husky” back in the day, and I was embarrassed to have to wear them. That would be very un-PC now, but hey, it was true. I was husky. I needed to hear the truth.