Using Sunk Costs To Your Advantage

Most people have things they’re striving for, things they want to be.  For many it’s to lose weight and live healthier.  Or maybe it’s to start that successful podcasting business. 

A common trap in modern society is to look at the gap between where you are and where you want to be, and to buy stuff to try to fill it.  There’s no shortage of companies promising you’ll get thin and fit if you only buy their product.

Using Sunk Costs To Your Advantage

Buying These Does Not Make You A Runner

But buying an expensive bike won’t make you a cyclist.  You’ve got to put in the long hours and ride it to do that.  And buying running shoes will fail to make you a runner, actual running is necessary.  Sorry.  

Similarly, a nice new microphone, pop screen, and editing software will not make a successful podcast.  Good content, long hours, and hard work do. 

You can’t buy what you want to be.  Closing the gap between where you are now and where you want to be costs time and effort, not money.

I’ve surely been guilty of trying to buy my way to a new goal.  For instance, after deciding I wanted to start an oil painting hobby years ago I went out and spent some good money on paints, canvases, and other supplies. 

What I didn’t spend as much time on was actually reading about and practicing how to mix paints.  I quit after deciding I disliked it.  I’m still not sure if my dislike resulted from a lack of trying, or from the disappointment that the stuff I bought didn’t make it easier to do. 

 

Sink In

But sometimes spending money by using the concept of “sunk costs” does work to help me close a gap.  A sunk cost is a cost that has already been incurred and cannot be recovered.  Like many investors, I have a bit of a history with sunk costs.

Take racing.  Whenever I find my running or cycling to be stagnant, I know it’s time to sign up for a race.  Something happens when I click “submit” on a race website and commit $50 or $100 to an event that lights a fire in me. 

Most races don’t give refunds, that money is gone.  So being that I’m pretty good at money and don’t like wasting it, the financial commitment to the race motivates the hell out of me.  

Once I pay, it’s game on.

It’s a sunk cost, it ain’t coming back.  And damn if I’m not going to get my money’s worth. 

So when I do this my training tends to go into hyper-drive.  I start getting results I would not have gotten had I not spent money on the race. 

This strategy works for me mostly because of the spent money, but to be honest, partly because I’m a bit competitive.  As much as I don’t want to delve into the ill-advised depths of comparison, a part of me is somewhat competitive.  It mostly manifests itself by being competitive against my old self.  I always want to beat my personal records because it gives me this funny delusion that I’m holding off age and will live forever.

Using Sunk Costs To Your AdvantageBut I’m also a bit competitive against others, even though I’d rather not be.  When I’m surrounded by hundreds of others at the starting line of a race, I get motivated.  Something clicks.  I can dig deeper, and suffer more. 

Recently I used my sunk cost strategy to great effect.  My running fitness has been declining since last summer.  Some of it has been a mild case of sciatica, but most of it has been lackadaisical effort. 

By February I knew I needed a motivational tool, it had been too long since I did a race.  So I found a cool 6 mile trail run and signed up. 

Proof, $60 spent.  Game on.

Sure enough, I started putting in the training miles – and most importantly the faster miles – that I had been avoiding.  The ones that hurt.

How did it go?

I came in 7th in my age group out of 38 racers!  That’s one of my best placings ever in a running race! 

 

Buying Motivation

In the end, I do agree you can’t buy what you want to be.  Becoming successful at anything – be it losing weight or podcasting requires you to put in the hard work.  You can’t just buy the necessary stuff and hope it’s going to magically happen.

But if you’re like me and don’t like to waste money I do see a place for buying motivation.  You may be able to use sunk costs as a catalyst for change.

Instead of “put your money where your mouth is”, it’s “put your money where your goals are” then chase that investment and make it pay off. 

Your turn readers – Have you ever used sunk costs to motivate yourself to do something or to reach a goal?

Subscribe To New Posts Here!

Dave @ Accidental FIRE

I reached financial independence and semi-retired in my mid-40's through hard work, smart living, and investing. This blog chronicles my journey and explores many aspects of personal finance including the psychological and behavioral factors that drive our habits.

You may also like...

26 Responses

  1. Completely agree on this one. I’ve been known to make a purchase or two to provide that bit of motivation I’ve been lacking in something, but it usually works only when I’ve already been committed to something and find that commitment waning a little bit.

    But, like you said, it doesn’t always work. I hate running. So, I know that if I buy new tennis shoes that isn’t going to make me enjoy something that I’ve never enjoyed.

    TPP

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      You’re right, if you don’t enjoy running it won’t help. But it can work for those who don’t mind running but have been slacking, like me.

  2. xrayvsn says:

    Great spin on sunk costs Dave, which is usually thought of as a negative thing.

    I agree once you put money into some endeavor, you try to give it your best effort to justify that expense.

    Even though it really wasn’t that much to begin with, once I actually charged money to start a website, I felt I had to give it at least a good college effort and try my best to blog (the results of that are still debatable, lol)

  3. How many times in my younger days did I take a fancy to something new and buy things to make it easier. We all learn the same lessons with that, don’t we? It rarely works.

    When I was running ( a LONG time ago), I found, like you, entering a race stepped up my training. It can be a slippery slope, though. Your exercise with the painting supplies is a perfect example. I’ve had many of those.

    Good stuff, Dave. As always.

  4. i always have 2 pairs of decent running shoes around, one at work and one at home, but they haven’t always gotten much use. otherwise i prefer to work out for free with equipment on hand….y’know shorts, shoes, regular t-shirt and have always avoided fancy technical gear. i see people running by on my busy street with 100’s of dollars in shiny equipment and clothing and water bottles (who the hell needs to carry water to run 2-3 miles? you’re not in the desert here in buffalo). i know there is some amount of tech gear to go along with that, whether it’s a fit bit or what have you. most of the real work happens alone with no cheering or fanfare to make any progress. take step 1, rest, repeat step one and get better….or do the common thing and go for a week and pivot to some costly cross fit or whatever the latest fad is that everyone is doing that costs a bunch of dollars.

    i might sign up for a 5k in virginia beach while i’m on vacation there. i never really set out to run a particular race but i can’t see wasting this newfound fitness. i about crapped my pants when i found out what races cost nowadays. 40 american bucks! i wholeheartedly agree that once that money is spent it can be a motivator. i hope it works out that way with our studio renovation and the painting up there is prolific. good stuff you’ve written here.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Dude, you should totally take advantage. At 51 if you run a sub-18 5k you’d very likely either win or be on the podium. Honestly here in the DC area at some races you’d still have to go faster as we have tons of great athletes, but either way you’d be up there with the big dogs.

      Find a race that gives away some nice swag for age-class winners. Then get the swag 🙂

  5. PFI says:

    Yep, I definitely use events to get me to commit more to training. Especially with biking, I’ve ridden so many miles around here that it can be hard to motivate to go out for a long training slog on the same old roads. A challenging event a few months out will get me out even if my own willpower wouldn’t simply be enough. I don’t pay for a gym so that helps offset the costs a bit. I find the new experience, the motivation to train, and the extra push I get from cycling around others is almost always worth it.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      I hear ya, the same old roads do get boring and it becomes a mental test. But throw some money down and boom, game on!

  6. Steveark says:

    That’s very clever, applying sunk costs as a motivator. And I get it, I ran a lot of marathons in my younger days but run shorter distances now. But back then, signing up for a marathon was a huge motivator. And telling my running buddies I had signed up created a lot of accountability. And honestly, I probably would have died rather than not finish every race I ever started.

  7. There is some proof out there that putting money into something does make you more motivated. Don’t quote me on that. lol! On the other hand I also know people who pay for their Equinox gym membership each month (at least $120/month) and NEVER go! Ouch! Congrats on the race!

    • Katie Camel says:

      Haha! I’m opposite from those Equinox members. The more I’m paying for a gym, the more I’m determined to go. As I’ve learned, I’m willing to pay a premium for a nice gym that inspires me to go versus a crappy cheap gym that deters me from going. I actually really enjoy going to the gym, but I had to leave a cheap dungeon of a gym with awful music blaring above my head and pay top dollar for a pretty gym with floor-to-ceiling windows. Now I go all the time! I guess for me money is a partial motivator in that it gets me there on the days I want to stay home.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Wow, $120 a month. I’d be Arnold Schwarzenegger if I paid that much for a gym membership. I’d be a lifting fool!

      Thanks Tonya!

  8. That’s pretty good. I use sunk cost to go to the gym. I’m already paying so I have to use it.
    Buying equipment doesn’t seem to work, though. We got plenty of stuff that we rarely use.
    We’ll have a garage sale this summer to get rid of some stuff.

  9. Using this as a commitment device is a good idea. Hard to not buckle down when you have something to lose on the line.

  10. The concept of sunk cost has never really worked for me. I am very careful with money so I will never put down a meaningful amount of money if I don’t intend on getting the benefit. Therefore, it isn’t the sunk cost of money that motivates me to go but that I really wanted to go in the first place.

    In situations when I was unsure if I wanted to go, I would only put down money if it is insignificant to me. Therefore, I wouldn’t care if I don’t get the benefit from it. If the amount is insignificant to me, then the money as sunk cost doesn’t serve as motivation for me to go.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      I think we’re saying kinda the same thing. I put down a meaningful amount of money on a race with the intention of getting the benefit. And the drive to get the benefit motivates me.

  11. Abigail @ipickuppennies.net says:

    I could see this backfiring on me. The pressure of having spent the money could make it feel like a duty that grows in size and importance until it’s a stressor. But that’s probably just the depressive in me. Still, I think it’s great that you’ve found a way to motivate yourself *and* to not lose money!

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      I understand, it might not be a strategy for everyone. As long as you know yourself, that’s what’s most important!

Drop Me A Comment - What's On Your Mind?

Verified by MonsterInsights