Now Is Not The Time To Be Smug

Now Is Not The Time To Be SmugIn the past week I’ve seen some financial independence folks being a bit smug about this economic crisis that COVID-19 has caused.  At one level I get it, for those who have saved money, invested wisely, lived frugally, and avoided consumerism there’s naturally a certain amount of relief and even pride right now. 

I’m certainly in that camp, I’m very proud at how I’ve lived my life and that I’ve positioned myself so well for an event like this.  If you’ve done the same you should be proud too.

But there’s a difference between being proud and bragging about it to those who are suffering.  And remember that folks aren’t just suffering from money and job issues right now, they’re worried about the health of their family members. 

Stress levels and anxiety are through the roof.  And this is happening to a culture that has already been operating at high levels of anxiety, depression, mental health issues, and suicide.

For those of us who have lived frugally, saved money, invested wisely, and learned to live with what most others consider big inconveniences, this is not the time to be smug.

The people who make plenty enough to save but instead spend it all (I’m not talking about low income people here) aren’t bad people.  They’re people like anyone else, with families and hopes and dreams. 

But they probably haven’t come to a point in their lives where they’ve had to seriously address their relationship with money, consumerism, discipline, and values. 

This just might be the event that forces a sea change. 

 

Call To Action

Now Is Not The Time To Be SmugIf you’ve achieved financial independence and have a blog now’s the time to keep teaching, to keep telling your stories.  Now’s the time to persuade, to convince people that there’s another way.  This is the time to hunker down and write your best content.

Remember that old quote, the one about teaching someone to fish versus just giving them a fish?  This is the time to teach people to fish.  I’m all for charitable donations and make plenty myself, but the power to teach someone to change is a far greater power. 

The financial independence community is full of smart and accomplished people who’ve positioned themselves to handle an event like this.  Sure, many in the community are hurting too and some have even “fallen out of FI”, but most have surely put themselves in a far better position than the average American household that can’t handle a relatively small unexpected expense

So FI community, let’s rally.  Let’s use this event to solidify our commitment to smarter living, to buying less, to cultivating more discipline, and most importantly, to telling our stories so others might come along. 

Do it in your own way, with your own unique experiences.  I’ve convinced quite a few people to start their own blogs, not because my writing itself inspired them, but because I told them the truth.  And the truth is they have a unique story, no one else can tell it but them, and in a world of millions of people some out there will identify or see themselves in that story. 

It’s as simple as that.

 

Where Do We Go

Some are saying this event may be the death knell for the financial independence movement.  I say no way.  I think this event has the potential to expand our movement in a huge way. 

It shows we’re more relevant than ever.

Big events that affect everyone have a way of not only uniting, but of fomenting lasting change.  Only time will tell if this is one of those events.  And a lot of dust will have to settle.  That dust is gonna make a real mess of things, and already is.

Real sweeping changes that put more people on the path to financial independence will have a better chance of happening if we, the ones already here, do our best to show the way and model the example.  And save the smugness for a less stressful time.

 

Subscribe To New Posts Here!

Dave @ Accidental FIRE

I reached financial independence and semi-retired in my mid-40's through hard work, smart living, and investing. This blog chronicles my journey and explores many aspects of personal finance including the psychological and behavioral factors that drive our habits.

You may also like...

38 Responses

  1. Gars says:

    Interesting article by Manifest Investing at Seeking Alpha. Scroll down to MIMPAR.

    Author is Mark Robertson.

    https://expectingalpha.com/2020/03/18/hoping-for-a-pandemic-of-perspective/amp/?__twitter_impression=true

  2. Well said, and for those who need the technical definition: “having or showing an excessive pride in oneself or one’s achievements”.

    I have been doing a lot of my work “behind the scenes” from friends and family. Maybe now is a good time to change that mindset and help people we can actually see an touch. Well maybe not touch, right now.

    Take care, Sir.

    Max

  3. Amen. I believe the mainstream FI movement was sparked by the financial crisis, and I have little doubt that the current turmoil will only lead to more converts. The backlash we are experiencing now, I think, is more a result of jealousy and the hope for schadenfreude. But, I agree, we should be helping people and showing the way, not laughing at our (relatively) good fortunes.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Good point, there probably is some jealousy. There’s just a lot of emotion going around, and too much of it on social media.

  4. i wouldn’t mind seeing a little gratitude. for instance, i’m thankful to still have a job and that mrs. me still has 0.5 of a job. sure we could have maybe prematurely told our employers to go pound sand a while back and peaced out, but it was partly lucky that we did not. i think it’s partly a generational thing that we’re callused to work we don’t necessarily love but can surely tolerate. there are surely lessons to be learned here but bragging about your relative successes is probably not the message. life is strange and getting harder across the board and will likely get stranger and harder before it gets better. buckle up.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      I agree Freddy. I’m proud of my position but also grateful, and those come from different places. I like your comment about jobs that we “don’t necessarily love but can surely tolerate”. Well stated.

      I’m buckled, it’s gonna be a wild ride

      • Andy Locatelli says:

        I’m in the boat of having a job that I’m not passionate about (working for a provincial government) but overall tolerating it since it offers, among other things, good working conditions accompanied by a good salary and benefits package and a social purpose to what I do. Mostly, though, I’ve stayed for one overriding reason: I’m not FI but I’m kind of not far away from it, and any interruption in income over the next few years would derail my planning and imperil my situation. I’m at stage 2 (Stability) according to J.D. Roth’s stages of financial independence, and as much as there are many moments of impatience in my process, my guaranteed job and eventual pension are worth the current and ongoing investment of my life energies.

        I write all that because I really am grateful to have the good fortune and the personal wherewithal to be in a place where the current situation means mostly a series of inconveniences without having to be stressed about income and bills. I’ve been very disciplined over the past ten years, during which time I needed to pay off student debt on a salary that was pretty low for many years, but I also had the fortune to fall into a good position to be able to do so and have a reliable source of income that has become, over time, pretty comfortable.

        It seems to me that that kind of message will go a longer way to helping people realise how they can implement strategies that further their true life goals than smugness ever will.

  5. Prepare2FIRE says:

    Spot on Dave. I was troubled when I saw tweets about how smart someone was to make some financial moves before the #@!% hit the fan. I call that damn lucky. Let’s make sure we’re helping the next wave of FI understand how to navigate these storms -either through dedicated process or more importantly through our own mistakes.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Lucky indeed, no one could have timed this. A cycling friend of mine moved a bunch of money from stocks to bonds in early Feb – by luck – for various family reasons. She’s not pretending to be a wizard, she’s just enjoying her luck.

  6. Ed says:

    I couldn’t agree more. Now isn’t the time to rail at people about not having an emergency fund – but it certainly is the time to talk about how to build one for next time. I feel so lucky to be where we are at the moment, that money isn’t part of our anxiety. Rather than make me feel superior, it just makes me want to help others get there. Thanks for saying it!

  7. A very timely post Dave and right on the money (no pun intended)!

    I’m glad to see all the supportive comments and agree this is no time to be smug. At the moment I’m writing an article about achieving a successful retirement. Guess what, it’s not about having saved massive amounts of money! In fact, it’s more about the important things in life and finding balance.

    We all know lots of folks haven’t saved enough and often have hit a major financial set back. These can include job loss, divorce, putting kids through college, health issues, etc. For myself, I’m grateful for what I have and will continue to strive to make a difference in others lives.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      “Finding the important things in life and balance” I think many are going to discover those things in the next weeks and months. Too bad it had to happen this way.

  8. Tawcan says:

    Well said Dave. Now than ever, it’s time to spread the message about FIRE and good personal finance practices.

  9. Very refreshing and necessary perspective. Now is not the time for shaming or “I told you so’s” but rather for encouragement and inspiration. I’ve heard a fair number of comments about how this will wipe out the FIRE community, but I believe it’s going to be rather the opposite. Our spending is at an all time low, and could go lower if we really needed. I think many others are going to realize the beauty of spending only on the necessities, and hopefully come out of this stronger than ever.

  10. It’s tough right now and people are struggling. We have to hunker down and get through this tough period. Lots of people will realize their employers aren’t their friends. Many will look for a different alternative once we come out of this, just like the last recession. I think this will be a catalyst that expand the FIRE movement.
    Stay healthy!

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      I’m glad you agree with my assessment Joe as you’re one of the originals in this space and have a unique and respected opinion on it. Let’s keep putting out the content – I know you will!

  11. G. Brian Davis, SparkRental says:

    I agree, the FIRE movement is more relevant than ever in the wake of this catastrophe. Who doesn’t wish they’d saved more money right now, that they were in a more secure financial position right now? I think the fundamentals of a high savings rate and investing for financial independence will become more appealing than ever in the months and years to come.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      “Who doesn’t wish they’d saved more money right now”

      Bingo. Let’s just hope that feeling sticks with them. We will recover, they will have another chance.

  12. veronica says:

    There is one other thing that I think the FIRE community can do. Since we have saved and planned, we are better prepared to weather this lock down (Day 11 in Spain. Hopefully only another 19 more to go!) and the recession (just my guess at this point) that will ensue. I’m not planning to blow my budget, but I will do my best to support the businesses that are being wrecked during the shut down. And I’m throwing down the gauntlet to the rest of the FIRE community – what can YOU do to help an independent business back onto its feet, either now or when the restrictions are lifted? Now is not the time to worry about the lowest price, the best deal. Now is the time to think how your money can do the most social good while getting you what you need.

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      Awesome point Veronica and another call to action – go out and support small businesses! I don’t want to get on my soapbox about Starbucks etc, but this one of the reasons why I’ve never given them money, because they don’t need it and they’ve pushed out independent coffee shops that have unique character all across America and the world. Go support your local coffee shop, (assuming you’re lucky enough to have one left).

      Off soapbox 😉

    • Andy says:

      Thanks for making such an important point and highlighting its importance long-term. As people have to prioritize how they spend their limited resources, I’m hoping this a golden moment for people to see the benefits of supporting small businesses, artists, and non-profits that build community resilience.

  13. Mr. Tako says:

    Thanks for this Dave. Now is not the time to be a smug ass-hat. People are dying, many are unemployed and wondering where the next rent check is coming from. It’s tough times for many.

    Frankly, it’s time to lend a hand, not act like a jerk just because you saved a bit more.

  14. Jordan says:

    Well said Dave. #stayhumble

  15. I am so glad you wrote about this! I actually haven’t seen too much of this but I am still very new to the FIRE community (and possibly not following the “right” websites/pages). Your post has inspired me to reach out to my friends and family to see if I can help them with their emergency fund. As someone who is financial stable this is a great way I can help make someone’s burden less painful. I appreciate the inspiration. Cheers to a brighter future and more resilient peeps!

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      That’s an awesome thing to do in reaching out like that. You’re gonna go far in this community 🙂

      Thanks for the great comment and for stopping by!

  16. John Smith says:

    The current pandemic, I think, is different from the financial crisis of 2008-2009, but now it can lead to a financial and housing crisis. And it scares! I am new to investing and saving. Basically I studying the experience of others, and I really want to be financially independent …

    • Dave @ Accidental FIRE says:

      I agree this is different than 08-09. This wasn’t a bank or lending collapse, this is entirely different an how it will play out will likely be different too. Good luck on your journey to FI!

  17. Rohit Joshi says:

    What an apt timing of writing this article. People are already facing a financial crisis due to pandemic, and now it’s their time to plan their finances properly to prevent this situation from arising again. Also, writing and sharing experiences help others understand and learn from scenarios.

  18. Kunal Shinde says:

    Thank you for sharing this Post. People are actually facing financial crises due to this Lockdown. and Definetly this article is going to help them to manage this situation. Perfect timing to post this article.

Drop Me A Comment - What's On Your Mind?

Verified by MonsterInsights